Tutorials >> Articles
>> Autodesk 3ds Max, Maya
3ds Max or Maya, Which is
3DS Max and Maya are two of
Autodesk’s most prominent 3D animation and rendering software programs. Many
aspiring graphic artists and animators are often confused about which software
is the best for their purposes whether it is animation or rendering projects. If
you are one of these aspiring artists, and are trying to figure out which
software is best for you then this article will help you to understand the key
differences between the two and help you make a well informed decision.
What is your purpose?
The first thing you will need to figure out is what you want to
do with your rendering software, Maya or 3ds Max. The two programs are owned by
the same company and are geared at two sets of people. 3Ds Max was originally
designed for architectural, game construct, and visualization artists and Maya
was geared towards film and TV animators. Each of the two software options has
specific tools which are unique to them based on their target users.
Autodesk is an American software company which focuses mainly on
the production of software geared towards 3D design. They provide a wide array
of options for fields such as architecture, construction, engineering,
entertainment, manufacturing, and media industries. Two of the most popular
software packages they offer for 3D design purposes are the “3Ds Max” and “Maya
3Ds Max Overview
3Ds Max is a
software suite offering a comprehensive set of rendering, 3D modeling,
compositing, and animation options. Autodesk 3Ds Max is focused mainly on people
who need to develop 3d animations for architectural or gaming purposes. It has a
very clean and powerful, CAD style interface.
1) Modeling and texturing
3Ds Max offers
several features ideal for modeling and texturing such as mesh and surface
modeling, as well as an editing and texture assignment mode. In the more recent
versions of the software, vector map support is present along with the ability
to find material design, shading, and substance procedure textures.
You can use 3Ds Max for
animation with the track view re-timing, and populate crowd animation modes. You
will always have the animated deformer mode and have access to rigging tools,
and character animation tools. Along with these great futures comes the ability
to insert dynamics and effects such as fur, hair, and cloth simulation. You have
the ability to control the particle flow and use rigid-body dynamics.
3) 3D Rendering
3Ds Max is ideal for 3D
rendering because of the vector displacement map support, perspective matching,
and a slate compositing editor. You can always find DX 11 viewpoint rendering,
Iray rendering, and active shade rendering. You can also use the render pass
system with the Nitrous accelerated graphics core to soup up all your graphics
3Ds Max offers a free trial mode of 30 days with several awesome
features for you to test before you invest in it. The UI, workflow, and pipeline
will allow you to use a configurable user interface, as well as have access to
collaborative workflows with containers. You can pan and zoom in 2D as well as
integrate Adobe Effects. Online support and training are included with the 3Ds
package and no credit card is required for their amazing trial.
If you want to get a free student software package, you will
need to download a 3-year license. If you want more information on this, check
out their site’s education community. You can always extend your animation
work-flow with 3Ds Max entertainment creation suite as well for an even wider
array of amazing rendering features.
Maya 3D is a
software suite offering a comprehensive set of animation, rendering, modeling,
and compositing and simulation options. It has an interface like a Forge and is
very flexible and powerful. It is however less intuitive than the 3Ds Max
software. It is geared mostly towards the film and entertainment industry and
the newest releases of the software offer next-gen display technology, new tools
for handling complex data operations, accelerated modeling workflows and much
Maya 3D is not geared as heavily towards animation as its
counterpart 3Ds Max, however you will have access to some great features such as
a camera sequencer mode, symmetry and joint centering mode, character creation,
and grease pencil modes. General 3D animation tools are also available, but the
heat map skinning, and Trax clip matching modes, editable motion trails and atom
animation transfer mode are pretty cool.
2) Dynamics and Effects
Maya nHair and Maya fur are two cool features which are good
when rendering monsters r animals. Maya offers a bullet physics mode, rigid and
soft-body dynamics and Maya fluid effects. With Maya you also have the ability
to use the cloth rendering and particle rendering options.
3) 3D Rendering
Professional camera tracking, toon shader options, and a
next-gen viewpoint shading and display option are some of the reasons why people
in the film industry prefer this software suite. Along with these options, you
can use Maya for its paint effects, procedural textures, as well as rendering,
camera, and shading features
Maya is available from Autodesk with a 30 day free trial just
like 3Ds Max, however, if you are just learning how to use the software, Maya 3D
is usually more difficult to use since it is not as intuitive as its counterpart
and usually takes about 3 months to learn. According to many reviews, this is
one of Maya’s biggest cons since users need to familiarize themselves with the
software once they get it. If you need to learn more about it you can always
visit Maya’s section on the education boards of the Autodesk website.
Autodesk Maya vs 3ds
Some of the benefits of purchasing 3Ds Max suite as opposed to a
Maya 3D suite are that you will have access to 7 features not present in Maya.
These would be vector map support, parade texture assignment and editing
options, character and rigging tools options, track view re-timing, and animated
deformers. If you choose Maya instead of 3Ds, you would only
gain the greasing pencil, atom transfer, UV’s, and color-per-vertex and normal
modes. It is your decision to go with Maya or 3ds max.
If you need a more comprehensive review and comparison of the
main features check out MAYA 3D and
on the Autodesk website. I hope you found this Maya vs Max article informative,
and you can finally decide to try Maya, 3ds max, or some other 3D software
If you liked this
tutorial, please share with your friends:
You might like to read some
Autodesk 3ds Max Introduction
3ds Max Student program
You might like to read some of
our 3ds Max tutorials: